(Revised 1/98)
The making of cloth or yarn from fiber. Entry should be skein or on spool; no woven cloth, embroidery, etc. Multiple skeins/spools of the same product may be entered to show quantity produced. Entrant should note fiber used and means of spinning(drop spindle, hand distaff, wheel, etc.)
Novice Intermediate Advanced
SPINNING - NOVICE
DOCUMENTATION (0-4 points) Must have at least a 3X5 card. More is acceptable. Give one point for each of the following that is present:
- Identification/Description of the entry.
- Approximate date and place/nationality in history that the entry is modeled upon.
- Includes materials/tools list OR states method used to complete entry.
- Cites at least one reference, either illustrative (pictures) or descriptive relating to either A) period use of such item OR B) period method of constructing such item OR C) both A & B.
AUTHENTICITY (0-4 points)
- 0:Blatantly modern in some aspect (Ex. man-made fiber, modern color, etc.)
- 1:Generally period, with some obviously modern elements (Ex. used electric wheel to produce period looking results), OR obvious mixture of materials or techniques from radically different cultures or periods.
- 2:Overall period product and process, with minor inconsistencies (Ex. used authentic fibers commercially prepared for spinning)
- 3:Period product and process with no inconsistencies
- 4:Special effort to achieve a completely period product by use of period raw materials, tools, etc. Completely period process without modern shortcuts. (Ex. sheared own sheep or grew own fiber plants, made period wheel, etc.)
COMPLEXITY (1-5 points)Rank the ambition of the entry, not the workmanship, on a scale of 1 to 5 based on the following:
- difficulty of spinning method used
- difficulty of fiber used
- fineness of thread
- preparation and finishing methods (shearing, combing, harvesting, bleaching, waxing, etc.)
- scope of endeavor (length and number of skeins, number of plies, etc.)
WORKMANSHIP (1-5 points) Rank the success of the attempt on a scale of 1 to 5 based on the following:
- choice of materials, tools, methods: is combination suitable?
- form: is it of intended fineness? uniform in weight, twist, strength?
- function and durability: will product stand up to its intended use?
CREATIVITY (1-6 points)
- 1:Entrant used standard modern process with no alteration or innovation.
- 2:Entrant followed modern directions for a process equivalent to that used in period to that used in period, with no innovation or original input.
- 3:Evidence of logical, original work in choice of fibers OR methods.
- 4:Evidence of logical, original work in choice of fibers AND methods.
- 5:Creative interpolation in developing techniques; much innovation logical to period context; unusual but logical combination of fiber or techniques.
- 6:Original, innovative combination of period materials and techniques to create a product appropriate for a specific use.
NOTE: Extra points may be awarded for start-to-finish processing.
QUALITY (1-6 points) Evaluate the work as a whole.
NOTE: This category is subjective; however, the judge should take into account prior category scores, aesthetic appeal, presentation, intuitive response, and other such items not previously addressed.
SPINNING - INTERMEDIATE
DOCUMENTATION (0-4 points) Must have at least 1 page, 2-3 pages preferable. More is acceptable. Give one point for each of the following that is present:
- Identification/Description of the entry plus the approximate date and place/nationality in history that the entry is modeled upon.
- Listing of fiber (materials) used in entry's construction and intended use of the entry.
- Describes method(s) of spinning used to create entry (may include reasons for why a certain process or material was used).
- Cites at least two references, either illustrative (pictures) or descriptive relating to either A) period use of such item OR B) period method of constructing such item OR C) both A & B.
AUTHENTICITY (0-4 points)
- Blatantly modern in some aspect (Ex. man-made fiber, modern color, etc.)
- Generally period, with some obviously modern elements (Ex. used electric wheel to produce period looking results), OR obvious mixture of materials or techniques from radically different cultures or periods.
- Overall period product and process, with minor inconsistencies (Ex. used authentic fibers commercially prepared for spinning)
- Period product and process with no inconsistencies
- Special effort to achieve a completely period product by use of period raw materials, tools, etc. Completely period process without modern shortcuts. (Ex. sheared own sheep or grew own fiber plants, made period wheel, etc.)
COMPLEXITY (1-5 points) Rank the ambition of the entry, not the workmanship, on a scale of 1 to 5 based on the following:
- difficulty of spinning method used
- difficulty of fiber used
- fineness of thread
- preparation and finishing methods (shearing, combing, harvesting, bleaching, waxing, etc.)
- scope of endeavor (length and number of skeins, number of plys, etc.)
WORKMANSHIP (1-5 points) Rank the success of the entry on a scale of 1-5 based on the following:.
- choice of materials, tools, methods: is combination suitable?
- form: is it of intended fineness? uniform in weight, twist, strength?
- function and durability: will product stand up to its intended use?
CREATIVITY (1-4 points)
- 1:Entrant used standard modern process with no alteration or innovation.
- 2:Entrant followed modern directions for a process equivalent to that used in period to that used in period, with no innovation or original input.
- 3:Evidence of logical, original work in choice of fibers or methods
- 4:Creative interpolation in developing techniques; much innovation logical to period context (Ex. built or adapted tools for specific type of period spinning, unusual but logical combination of fiber or techniques, etc.)
NOTE: Extra points may be awarded for start-to-finish processing.
QUALITY (1-8 points) Evaluate the work as a whole
NOTE: This category is subjective; however, the judge should take into account prior category scores, aesthetic appeal, presentation, intuitive response, and other such items not previously addressed.
SPINNING - ADVANCED
DOCUMENTATION (0-4 points)Must have at least 3 pages of discussion (NOT including visuals and bibliography). More is acceptable. Give score based on the following:
- 0:No documentation
- 1:Some documentation (time, place, fiber, method of spinning)
- 2:Same as #1 with at least one citation of a period example, but little or discussion of period practice, OR some discussion of techniques or materials, but no period examples cited.
- 3:Same as #2 with citation of at least one period example, with discussion of techniques or materials, but no period examples cited.
- 4:#3 with very complete examples and discussion, including rationale for techniques and fibers used in this entry, their appropriateness to each other, and the appropriateness of product to intended use. Explains original research or experiment. Explains any deviations or variations from period norm.
AUTHENTICITY (0-4 points)
- 0:Blatantly modern in some aspect (Ex. man-made fiber, modern color, etc.)
- 1:Generally period, with some obviously modern elements (Ex. used electric wheel to produce period looking results), OR obvious mixture of materials or techniques from radically different cultures or periods.
- 2:Overall period product and process, with minor inconsistencies (Ex. used authentic fibers commercially prepared for spinning)
- 3:Period product and process with no inconsistencies
- 4:Special effort to achieve a completely period product by use of period raw materials, tools, etc. Completely period process without modern shortcuts. (Ex. sheared own sheep or grew own fiber plants, made period wheel, etc.)
COMPLEXITY (0-6 points) Rank the ambition of the entry, not the workmanship, on a scale of 0-6 based on the following:
- difficulty of spinning method used
- difficulty of fiber used
- fineness of thread
- preparation and finishing methods (shearing, combing, harvesting, bleaching, waxing, etc.)
- scope of endeavor (length and number of skeins, number of plys, etc.)
WORKMANSHIP (0-6 points) ) Rank the success of the entry on a scale of 0-6 based on the following:
- choice of materials, tools, methods: is combination suitable?
- form: is it of intended fineness? uniform in weight, twist, strength?
- function and durability: will product stand up to its intended use?
CREATIVITY (0-4 points)
- 0:entrant used standard modern process with no alteration or innovation
- 1:Entrant followed modern directions for a process equivalent to that used in period to that used in period, with no innovation or original input.
- 2:Evidence of logical, original work in choice of fibers or methods
- 3:Creative interpolation in developing techniques; much innovation logical to period context (Ex. built or adapted tools for specific type of period spinning, unusual but logical combination of fiber or techniques, etc.)
- 4:Original, innovative combination of period materials and techniques to create a product appropriate for a specific period use. Start-to-finish processing. Development of original methods or shortcuts that would have been possible in period and logical to the period craftsman.
QUALITY (1-6 points) Evaluate the work as a whole.
NOTE: This category is subjective; however, the judge should take into account prior category scores, aesthetic appeal, presentation, intuitive response, and other such items not previously addressed.